This came out great! I was always impressed with the way you did Oekakis so yeah.. nice to see more of them Rouge's nose is intentionally pink, right? XD I think that makes her look a little amusing.. but everything else looks fine. I like her lipstick and the color for her eye-shadow. You did well with the effect of the shiny wand and stuff.. so yeah.
The pumpkin is shaped really weirdly, though "XD;" Maybe it's just an "illusion" or so because it's being covered, but I don't know. It's otherwise great!
No, I thought it was black XD *Checks on google, quickly* Like.. it stuck out like a sore thumb because it didn't seem like an official color..
.. Yeah, it's black XD But it's not really something horrible or terrible, really.. I thought it was going along with the costume and it wouldn't look any worse if you changed it.. so yeah XD You can always just say "It's with the costume!" if anyone else asks =>